Conflict

Tell me about a time you disagreed with your manager.

Why interviewers ask this

Interviewers want to see two things at once. First, that you have actual judgment and will push back when something is wrong. Second, that you can do it without making it personal or breaking the working relationship. Candidates who only show one of those signals usually fail this question.

STAR tip

Pick a real disagreement with stakes — not a small preference call. Show how you raised it, what you tried to learn from your manager before pressing harder, and how you both moved forward. End with what happened, even if your manager was right.

Sample answers

Marketing Lead

My manager wanted to cut our podcast sponsorships and move the whole budget into paid social. I disagreed because we had data showing podcast attribution was undercounted in our last-touch model. Instead of pushing back in the meeting, I booked a thirty-minute walk-and-talk and asked her what success looked like for her by the end of the quarter. Once I understood she needed a clear cost-per-acquisition number for the board, I came back two days later with a small experiment: hold one podcast slot, run the same budget on social, and compare assisted conversions over three weeks. She said yes. The result was that podcasts came in at a thirty-two percent lower fully-loaded CPA than social over that window. We kept the slot. The bigger lesson was that what looked like a strategy disagreement was actually a measurement disagreement, and I would have spotted that sooner if I had asked about her board commitments first.

Engineering Manager

My director wanted to ship a refactor without writing a migration plan, because the timeline was tight. I disagreed and said so directly: we had two unfinished migrations from the previous year, and a third would block our team for months. I did not lead with that. I led with a question — what was driving the deadline? It turned out the real pressure was a customer demo, not the refactor itself. We ended up scoping a two-week feature stub that satisfied the demo, then doing the migration properly the following quarter. Demo went well. The migration shipped six weeks later with a clean rollback path. I learned to ask what is actually due before I argue about how to do the thing.

Common mistakes

  • Picking a disagreement that was actually trivial, like a tool choice
  • Framing your manager as wrong and you as right — interviewers hear it
  • Skipping the part where you tried to understand their reasoning first
  • Ending the story with no resolution or follow-up
  • Pretending you have never disagreed with a manager — nobody believes that

Score your own answer free

Paste your answer to "Tell me about a time you disagreed with your manager.". Odin scores it on STAR coverage and rebuilds it line-by-line. No signup. 5 free scores per hour.

Free, no signup. 5 scores per hour without an account.

Practice this with real AI feedback

Odin runs voice-first mock interviews tailored to your resume and the job posting. You get STAR-method scoring and concrete suggestions on every answer.

Related questions

Tell me about a time you pushed back on a stakeholder.
Conflict
Tell me about a time you gave someone difficult feedback.
Communication
Tell me about a time you had to say no.
Conflict